I am about to watch Season 2 myself! However, my tastes run to bulky guys, and I love what happened to JA's face in his midtwenties (smile lines, a little broadening, stubble as a way of life), so unfortunately I doubt I will enjoy the prettiness quite as much. S1 has some good exploration of Max, and Logan is reasonably interesting too--I fear what I'll find in this next season.

I too would be very interested in fic recs, so if you come across any you like I'd love to hear about them.